2025 Mazda Miata vs. Toyota GR86: A Comprehensive Comparison

The 2025 Mazda Miata and Toyota GR86 stand out in the sports car segment due to their agility and performance. In this article, we compare these cars, focusing on why the Miata continues to dominate the small sports car market. This guide will help you make an informed decision about which model best fits your lifestyle.

Design and Aesthetics

The appearance of the Mazda Miata and Toyota GR86 differs significantly. The Miata stays true to its roots with a sleek, classic roadster design, smooth curves, and compact size. The GR86 features a more aggressive coupe styling, with angular lines and a muscular stance.

The Miata offers a driver-centered interior with a minimalist approach that keeps everything within easy reach. The GR86 features a sportier interior with more modern tech features, offering performance and convenience. The Miata is lightweight, tipping the scales at just 2,341 pounds for the base trim. The GR86 is slightly heavier at 2,811 pounds. This weight difference crucially affects handling.

Performance and Engineering

The Miata is equipped with a 2.0L inline-four engine that produces 181 horsepower and 151 lb-ft of torque. The GR86 boasts a larger 2.4L flat-four engine that delivers 228 horsepower and 184 lb-ft of torque. While the GR86 provides more power, the Miata’s lighter weight enhances its agility on the road. Both cars offer a choice between a manual and automatic transmission.

The Miata takes the lead in fuel economy, offering an impressive 26 mpg in the city and 34 mpg on the highway. The GR86 provides 20 mpg in the city and 27 mpg on the highway. This makes the Miata a more economical choice for daily driving.

Technology and Features

Both cars are equipped with modern infotainment systems. The Miata’s system is straightforward and user-friendly, focusing on the essential features, while the GR86 offers slightly more in terms of technology. Both vehicles offer several advanced driver-assistance features, incorporating safety technology without compromising the driving experience.

Safety and Reliability

Both the Miata and GR86 come with a suite of standard features to keep you protected on the road. While specific safety ratings for the 2025 models aren’t available yet, both Mazda and Toyota have strong reputations for building safe vehicles. Both cars stand out regarding their reliability. The Miata, in particular, has a long-standing reputation as a reliable, low-maintenance sports car, which contributes to its lower ownership cost over time.

Practicality and Versatility

The 2025 Mazda Miata is strictly a two-seater, while the Toyota GR86 technically has four seats, though the rear seats are best suited for small children or extra storage space. The Miata’s convertible top gives it an edge in terms of open-air fun, allowing you to soak up the sun at a moment’s notice.

Both cars are surprisingly practical for daily driving. They’re small enough to navigate tight city streets and parking spaces with ease. The Miata’s excellent fuel economy makes it a great choice for your commute if you want to inject some fun into your daily drive.

Pricing and Value

These two sports cars offer comparable pricing. The Miata starts at an MSRP of $30,170, while the GR86 comes in slightly higher at $30,435. Both offer excellent value for money, packing a lot of fun into a relatively affordable package.

The Miata often edges out the competition in terms of resale value. Its iconic status and loyal fan base mean that the Miata tends to retain its value well over time. This advantage, combined with its lower fuel consumption, makes the Miata a more economical choice in the long run.

Expert Reviews and Owner Feedback

Professional automotive reviewers consistently praise both the Miata and GR86 for their engaging driving dynamics and affordable price points. The Miata often receives extra accolades for its exhilarating sports car experience.

Owner feedback echoes these sentiments. Miata owners often speak of their cars with a passion that borders on reverence, praising the car’s reliability, fun factor, and sense of connection to the road. Although GR86 owners are also enthusiastic, they tend to focus more on the car’s practicality and everyday functionality.

The Verdict: Why the Miata Comes Out on Top

While both the 2025 Mazda Miata and Toyota GR86 are excellent sports cars, the Miata edges out the competition to claim the title of top small sports car. Its lightweight design and exceptional fuel economy make it ideal if you want to elevate your driving experience. The Miata’s convertible top adds an extra dimension of fun that the GR86 can’t match, turning every drive into an adventure.

Schedule a Test-Drive Today

If you’re in San Juan Capistrano, we invite you to visit Capistrano Mazda to experience the 2025 Mazda Miata firsthand. Our friendly team will answer any questions you may have and help you explore your financing options. Contact us today to schedule a test-drive to help you decide whether the Miata fits your lifestyle.